Truth-telling

In the second chapter of The Only Planet of Choice, which I am currently re-reading, the authors refer to a book called ‘Beyond the Limits’, about things like global warming and developing a sustainable future. With this in mind, coupled with a Joe Rogan interview I watched yesterday with Aubrey de Grey, a biomedical gerontologist who thinks we can science our way out of the problems caused by over-population (just as people think we can science our way out of “Covid-19” with a vaccine), I found a section titled Truth telling to be quite relevant to our present day, even though the book was published back in 1992 (by Meadows and Randers and sequel to ‘The Limits of Growth’).

The transition to a sustainable society might be helped by the simple
use of words like [visioning, networking, truth-telling, learning, and
loving] more often, with sincerity and without apology,
in the information streams of the world.

Visioning
Visioning means imagining, at first generally and then with increasing
specificity, what you really want. That is, what you really want, not
what someone has taught you to want, and not what you have learned
to be willing to settle for. Visioning means taking off all the constraints
of assumed “feasibility,” of disbelief and past disappointments, and letting
your mind dwell upon its most noble, uplifting, treasured dreams.
Some people, especially young people, engage in visioning with enthusiasm
and ease. Some people find the exercise of visioning painful,
because a glowing picture of what could be makes what is all the more
intolerable. Some people would never admit their visions, for fear of
being thought impractical or “unrealistic.” They would find this paragraph
uncomfortable to read, if they were willing to read it at all. And
some people have been so crushed by their experience of the world
that they can only stand ready to explain why any vision is impossible.
That’s fine; they are needed too. Vision needs to be balanced with skepticism.

There was a sound-bite on the radio today about aphantasia and how those who have an inability to recognise visual images in their mind tend to work in science. I found this quite odd and somewhat scary. Reading on…

Truth-telling
No, we are no more certain of the truth than anyone is. But we
often recognize an untruth when we hear one, coming from our own
mouths or those of others, and most particularly coming from advertisers
and from political leaders. Many of those untruths are deliberate,
understood as such by both speakers and listeners. They are put forth
to manipulate, lull, or entice, to postpone action, to justify self-serving
action, to gain or preserve power, or to deny an uncomfortable reality.
Lies distort the information stream. A system cannot function, especially
in time of peril, if its information stream is confused and distorted.
One of the most important tenets of systems theory … is that information should
not be deliberately distorted, delayed, or sequestered.

“All of humanity is in peril,” said Buckminster Fuller, “if each one
of us does not dare, now and henceforth, always to tell only the truth
and all the truth, and to do so promptly—right now.” Whenever you
speak in public, even to a public of one other person, you can counter
a lie or affirm a truth, as best you can see truth. You can deny the idea
that having more things makes one a better person, or you can endorse
it. You can question the idea that growth for the rich will help the
poor, or you can accept it. The more you can use your voice to counter
misinformation, the more manageable your society will ultimately be.
Here are some common biases and simplifications, verbal traps, untruths
that we have run into frequently in discussing limits to growth.
We think they need to be pointed out and avoided, if there is ever to
be clear thinking about the human economy and its relationship to the
earth.

I’m trying to remain hopeful about the world beyond ‘Covid-19’ but I fear we will just slip back into our old ways, letting this opportunity for a different path slip by.

6 comments

  1. If we were all to lie, act on our most base impulses, and generally act as heinous animals–the result would be the same: death. Death of everyone, everything, the Universe itself. All the posturing and projection of truth and vision is just denial that all is for naught.

  2. A fascinating article which makes total sense to me. I’ve always believed that truth is the way to go and if you see something that isn’t “right” you should immediately bring it up, no matter the source of the “untruth.” That puts a person at odds with every power-seeking aspect of the system and their sycophants but it opens one’s eyes to how much BS people swallow everyday and hardly ever give it any thought. It’s a foregone conclusion that we will return to our “wallowing in the mud” of predatory capitalism as “they” gradually release the constraints on their COVID-19 psy-op; that people will accept greatly restricted personal freedoms believing that such will render them physically safer personally. The collective beast hates and fears self-sacrifice. It knows at some subconscious level that it has outgrown its sustainability yet will do anything to not have to reduce itself to a sustainable level. Who is going to say, “Let me die, I’ve had a good (or not so good) long life already and I need to make room for the younger ones.”? So those who would propose “change” must do it within an impossible framework – over population and over consumption – hence their own efforts are based in untruthfulness.

    • Amazing things can happen when you follow truth, rather than ego, or fear; it’s not always easy, but each step in the right direction is progress. Thank you for your detailed and thought-provoking comment, and also the reblog.

  3. Reblogged this on ~Burning Woman~ and commented:
    A fascinating article which makes total sense to me. I’ve always believed that truth is the way to go and if you see something that isn’t “right” you should immediately bring it up, no matter the source of the “untruth.” That puts a person at odds with every power-seeking aspect of the system and their sycophants but it opens one’s eyes to how much BS people swallow everyday and hardly ever give it any thought. It’s a foregone conclusion that we will return to our “wallowing in the mud” of predatory capitalism as “they” gradually release the constraints on their COVID-19 psy-op; that people will accept greatly restricted personal freedoms believing that such will render them physically safer personally. The collective beast hates and fears self-sacrifice. It knows at some subconscious level that it has outgrown its sustainability yet will do anything to not have to reduce itself to a sustainable level. Who is going to say, “Let me die, I’ve had a good (or not so good) long life already and I need to make room for the younger ones.”? So those who would propose “change” must do it within an impossible framework – over population and over consumption – hence their own efforts are based in untruthfulness.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s